Document Type

Response/Comment

Publication Date

2016

Disciplines

Administrative Law | Comparative and Foreign Law | Constitutional Law | International Relations | Law | Law and Politics | Legal History

Abstract

My book asks Is Administrative Law Unlawful? Adrian Vermeule answers “No.” In support of his position, he claims that my book does not really make arguments from the U.S. Constitution, that it foolishly denounces administrative power for lacking legislative authorization, that it grossly misunderstands this power and the underlying judicial doctrines, and ultimately that I argue “like a child.”

My book actually presents a new conception of administrative power, its history, and its unconstitutionality; as Vermeule has noted elsewhere, it offers a new paradigm. Readers therefore should take seriously the arguments against the book. They also, however, should recognize that the book unavoidably has provoked a strong reaction. The question here, therefore, is whether Vermeule’s heated denunciation is more revealing about the book or about the difficulty of defending administrative power.

Comments

Copyright © 2016 Texas Law Review Association.

Share

COinS