The Question of Intervention: John Stuart Mill and the Responsibility to Protect
The question of when or if a nation should intervene in another country’s affairs is one of the most important concerns in today’s volatile world. Taking John Stuart Mill’s famous 1859 essay “A Few Words on Non-Intervention” as his starting point, international relations scholar Michael W. Doyle addresses the thorny issue of when a state’s sovereignty should be respected and when it should be overridden or disregarded by other states in the name of humanitarian protection, national self-determination, or national security. In this time of complex social and political interplay and increasingly sophisticated and deadly weaponry, Doyle reinvigorates Mill’s principles for a new era while assessing the new United Nations doctrine of responsibility to protect.
In the twenty-first century, intervention can take many forms: military and economic, unilateral and multilateral. Doyle’s thought-provoking argument examines essential moral and legal questions underlying significant American foreign policy dilemmas of recent years, including Libya, Iraq, and Afghanistan.
Yale University Press
New Haven, CT
"In this brilliant book Michael Doyle supplies a lucid history, exposition, and evaluation of the idea of non-intervention from its beginnings in natural law theorizing about doctrines of just war to recent and contemporary debates over Somalia, Rwanda, Kosovo, Ossetia, Libya, Syria, and elsewhere, as well as a thorough account of the evolving machineries of intervention since the creation of the United Nations. It is the best available work on its subject, and is likely to be widely discussed."
—Ian Shapiro, Yale University
"Intervention is the quintessential ethical challenge of international politics. Competing claims often appear irreconcilable. Duties are not clearly assigned and expectations change over time. Michael Doyle sorts out the arguments in clear, concise, and lively prose, telling a story that enables a principled approach to power politics. This is a landmark book for scholars, students, and policymakers alike – it will become the go-to resource for years to come.”
—Joel H. Rosenthal, Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs
"Michael Doyle straddles, as no one else does, the parallel worlds of theory and practice, international law and relations, politics and philosophy, and empirics and ethics. His book casts a uniquely penetrating light on the question of intervention.”
—Harold Hongju Koh, Sterling Professor of International Law, Yale Law School and former State Department Legal Adviser
"Since the 1990s ... the tension between the norm of state sovereignty and the need to prevent atrocities has become more intense ... In this magisterial study, Doyle provides the most thoughtful and searching exploration yet of this dilemma."
“Classical international theory at its best … a book full of insight: the tone dispassionate, the argument subtle, and clearly of considerable value to both scholars and practitioners alike.”
—J.E. Spence, International Affairs
International Relations | Political Science | Social and Behavioral Sciences
Center on Global Governance
Doyle, Michael W., "The Question of Intervention: John Stuart Mill and the Responsibility to Protect" (2015). Books. 243.