In this Response to Professor Peters, Professor Greenawalt argues that prescriptive equality does have meaningful normative force. Prescriptive equality plays a reinforcing role when it agrees with nonegalitarian justice and is not incoherent when it pulls against nonegalitarian justice. Specifically, when one individual has been treated better than is required by nonegalitarian justice, a similarly situated and significantly related individual who is aware of that treatment may merit equivalent treatment because of widespread and deep-seated feelings about equality.
Civil Rights and Discrimination | Jurisprudence | Law
"Prescriptive Equality": Two Steps Forward,
Harv. L. Rev.
Available at: https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/faculty_scholarship/2919